Observations Exit interviews Matched pairs
N Prevalence
n/%
(95% CI)
N Prevalence
n/%
(95% CI)
Don't know
(%)
N <5 counts
per cell
Agreement
(%)
Sensitivity
(95% CI)
Specificity
(95% CI)
AUC
(95% CI)
IF Criteria met
Failure to meet professional standards of care
Lack of informed consent process (e.g., examine without permission)?
724 89/12
(7-20)
724 65/9
(5-15)
0 723 No 92 53
(42-64)
97
(96-98)
0.75
(0.70-⁠0.80)
0.73 AUC
Skilled attendants absent at time of childbirth?
724 109/15
(7-31)
724 51/7
(3-14)
0 723 No 88 32
(24-42)
97
(96-99)
0.65
(0.60-0.69)
0.47 AUC
Poor rapport between women and providers
Denial or lack of birth companions during labour and childbirth?
724 114/16
(8-28)
724 98/14
(7-26)
0 723 No 94 74
(65-82)
98
(96-99)
0.86
(0.82-0.90)
0.86 AUC
IF
BA did not respect woman choice of preferred birth positions?
724 24/3
(2-7)
724 31/4
(2-10)
0 722 No 95 42
(22-63)
97
(95-98)
0.69
(0.59-0.79)
1.29 AUC
Health system conditions and constraints
Staffing shortages (perceived) during labour and childbirth?
724 129/18
(8-35)
724 67/9
(5-18)
0 724 No 90 47
(38-56)
99
(98-100)
0.73
(0.68-0.77)
0.52 AUC
Lack of privacy?
724 75/10
(3-31)
724 49/7
(1-30)
0 724 No 96 63
(57-74)
100
(99-100)
0.81
(0.76-0.87)
0.65 AUC