| Butts et al. (2020) Development, implementation and dissemination: Couples and Parent-Child Communication Workshops in Zambia |
HIV |
Zambia |
Quantitative
Impact evaluation
Pre-experimental pre-post single group design |
January -June 2017 |
Primary* = 6
Secondary** = 195 |
Readiness to conduct a workshop and implementation |
- Participant readiness to conduct a workshop was generally high in both Provinces
- Approximately half of the primary participants conducted workshops
|
6 districts across 2 provinces |
| Darras and van der Heide (2015) Implementing psychosocial methods to reinforce women's legal rights awareness training in Jordan |
Gender-based violence |
Jordan |
Mixed methods
Formative and impact evaluation
Pre-experimental pre-post 2 group design |
Not specified |
Primary = not specified
Secondary = 170 (approx.) |
Participant knowledge, legal awareness and participant perceptions of training methods |
- Participant knowledge and legal awareness increased in both methods of delivery (2x 1hour sessions and 2x 2.5hour sessions)
- Participants and facilitators preferred longer sessions
|
Single community |
| Foster et al. (2017) Community-based distribution of misoprostol for early abortion: evaluation of a program along the Thailand–Burma border |
Abortion |
Thailand & Burma |
Mixed methods
Outcome evaluation
Pre-experimental: post only single group design |
January 2012 - December 2014 |
Primary = 2
Secondary = 5 |
Pregnancy outcomes |
- 918 women were provided with misoprostol for early abortion
- 885 women (96.4%) were no longer pregnant at follow-up
- 29 women were pregnant at follow-up (3.2%)
- 4 women were lost to follow-up (0.4%)
|
Regional |
| Jones et al. (2015) HIV Prevention in Resource Limited Settings: A Case Study of Challenges and Opportunities for Implementation |
HIV |
Zambia |
Mixed methods
Process evaluation |
2009-2012 |
Primary = 130
Secondary = 52 |
Training delivery rates, providers’ intentions to initiate and continue provision of the program, comfort delivering the intervention, competence in the delivery of the intervention, number of clinics, staff trained, sessions, drop out and discontinuation |
Implementation addressed multiple issues relating to:
- training
- consultants
- decision making administration
- evaluation
- travel
- staff compensation
- ongoing quality assurance
|
Scale up to 4/10 provinces |
| Kohi et al. (2010) The Tanzania HIV/AIDS nursing education (THANE) preservice curriculum |
HIV |
Tanzania |
Quantitative
process & impact evaluation
Pre-experimental: Pre-post test single group design |
2009-2013 |
Primary = 18
Secondary = 300 |
HIV knowledge, confidence in teaching, and thoughts about HIV, participant satisfaction with the workshops, and implementation and dissemination of program |
Evaluation findings not reported in paper.
Development and implementation learnings included:
- Support from stakeholders is essential
- Challenges include: lack of resources, integrating training into existing systems, keeping content current
|
National scale up |
| Labrecque et al. (2013) Strengthening vasectomy services in Rwanda: introduction of thermal cautery with fascial interposition |
Vasectomy |
Rwanda |
Quantitative
Outcome evaluation
Pre-experimental: Post only single group design |
Primary training – 5 days in 2010
Scale up period unclear |
Primary = 3
Secondary = 46 (secondary training not reported in paper) |
Number of men who received vasectomies |
67 men received vasectomies |
5 rural health centres (scale up to 27 districts not reported in paper) |
| Lieber et al. (2019) Cervical Cancer Screening in HIV-Positive Farmers in South Africa: Mixed-Method Assessment |
HIV & cervical cancer |
South Africa |
Mixed methods
Process & impact evaluation
Pre-experimental: post only single group design |
Not provided |
Primary = not provided
Secondary = not provided |
Advancements in knowledge and skills of providers and improvements in knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours of participants, perspectives and experiences of participants and providers, gaps in the program that would inform improvements moving forward |
- Improved cervical cancer screening understanding and awareness report by participants
- Barriers included concerns about privacy and negative perceptions of medical care
- Trained healthcare workers displayed ongoing clinical competence
- Positive correlation identified between visual inspection with acetic acid (VIA) and Pap smear results
- Loss to follow up = approximately half of the first cohort of patients
- month-over-month change for overlapping 4 months of programming between 2015 and 2016 revealed
- 4.4% negative change in number of Pap smears
- 57% negative change in VIAs
|
Single farm-based HIV clinic site |
| Makins et al. (2018) FIGO postpartum intrauterine device initiative: Complication rates across 6 countries |
Long acting risible contraceptives |
Sri Lanka, India, Nepal, Bangladesh, Tanzania, and Kenya |
Quantitative
Outcome evaluation (post hoc analysis)
Pre-experimental: Post only single group design |
May 2014 to September 2017 |
Primary = 12-18
Secondary = 4,904 |
Complication rates following postpartum intrauterine device (PPIUD) insertion |
- 36 766 PPIUDs were inserted
- Expulsion rate = 2.6%
- Removal rate = 3.6%,
|
6 countries |
| Malama et al. (2020) A couple-focused, integrated unplanned pregnancy and HIV prevention program in urban and rural Zambia |
Unplanned pregnancy & HIV |
Zambia |
Quantitative
Outcome evaluation
Pre-experimental: post-only single group design |
2013-2016 |
Primary = 391
Secondary = 810 |
Number of staff trained, clients served, HIV infections averted, unplanned pregnancies averted |
- 1201 counsellors trained
- 120,535 urban and 87,676 rural couples received intervention
- 12,869 urban and 8279 rural adult HIV infections were estimated to be averted
- 98,626 unintended urban pregnancies were estimated to be averted
|
55 urban clinics
215 rural clinics
across 33 districts |
| Nyamathi et al. (2010) Delivery of a model HIV prevention and health promotion train-the-trainer program in India by homeopathy and Ayurveda practitioners and educators |
HIV |
India |
Quantitative
Impact evaluation
Pre-experimental: pre-post 2 group design |
2006
(12 months) |
Primary = 202
Secondary = 782 |
Change in knowledge of and attitudes regarding HIV/AIDS, number of secondary trainees trained by the primary trainees |
- Significantly increases in HIV/AIDS knowledge and attitude for both 1-day and 3-day primary training groups
- Ongoing improvements in both groups reported at 3- and 6-month post training
- 26% of participants who participated in the one-day program trained secondary trainees
- 36% of participants in the 3-day program trained secondary trainees
|
Metropolitan region (Delhi) |
| Pitipan et al. (2017) Fidelity Moderates the Association Between Negative Condom Attitudes and Outcome Behaviour in an Evidence-Based Sexual Risk Reduction Intervention for Female Sex Workers |
HIV |
Mexico |
Quantitative (post hoc analysis)
Outcome evaluation
Randomised Control trial design |
2004-2006 |
Primary = not reported
Secondary = not reported |
Attitudes toward condoms, fidelity of the implementation of the intervention |
- Only 15.1% (n=73) sessions were found to have demonstrate complete fidelity
- Negative condom attitudes predicted greater condomless sex at lower levels of fidelity,
- The effect of condom attitudes on condomless sex was weaker at higher levels of fidelity
|
13 clinics across 8 states |
| Renju et al. (2010) A process evaluation of the scale up of a youth-friendly health services initiative in northern Tanzania |
Adolescent SRH |
Tanzania |
Mixed methods
Process & impact evaluation
Pre-experimental: Pre-post single group design |
June 2004 - December 2008 |
Primary = 24
Secondary = 429 |
Knowledge on STI/HIV/AIDS transmission and prevention, knowledge on pubertal changes, attitudes towards condoms, confidentiality and young people’s rights to treatment, coverage, attendance, selection, motivation, experiences, attitudes, perceptions, characteristics, ownership, training content and delivery, levels of support, logistics and other external factors. |
- Improvements in trainers’ confidence and ability to lead were reported
- Significant improvements in HIV/AIDS and puberty knowledge following district-led training
- Significant improvements in attitudes towards condoms, confidentiality and young people’s rights to treatment following district-led training
- Compared to control health units, intervention health units scored higher in simulated patient scenarios for family planning and condom request, but lower in the STI scenario
- Selection and retention of trained health workers was key challenge for the scaling up
- Numerous contextual and structural constraints were challenges to the scaling up
|
Regional scale up |
| Sodhi et al. (2014) Supporting middle-cadre health care workers in Malawi: Lessons learned during implementation of the PALM PLUS package |
HIV & STIs
(& non SRH topics tuberculosis, malaria, asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease) |
Malawi |
Mixed methods
Process evaluation component of an RCT |
January 2010 to December 2011 |
Primary = 37
Secondary = 519 |
Trainee satisfaction and retention, patient clinical outcomes, programmatic lessons learned |
Key enablers included:
- Building peer support networks
- ensuring adequate training capacity
- building linkages to continuing professional development accreditation
- providing modest training budgets
Key barriers included:
- Staff turnover
- Financial training allowances
|
District scale up |
| Stormo et al. (2013) Findings and lessons learned from a multi-partner collaboration to increase cervical cancer prevention efforts in Bolivia |
Cervical cancer |
Bolivia |
Quantitative
Formative & impact evaluation
Pre-experimental: pre-post single group design |
September 2010 to December 2012 |
VIA & cryotherapy
Primary = 12
Secondary = 61
(approx. half of secondary trainees were trained by primary trainees) |
Knowledge gained, level of skill demonstrated in simulation exercises and oral presentations and ability to plan, implement a basic course on VIA and cryotherapy, and perceptions of course |
- Most VIA and cryotherapy course participants received a satisfactory post-test score
|
Regional |
| Tilahun et al. (2017) Improving contraceptive access, use, and method mix by task sharing Implanon insertion to frontline health workers: the experience of the Integrated Family Health Program in Ethiopia |
LARC |
Ethiopia |
Quantitative
Process and outcome evaluation
Pre-experimental: post only single group design |
Learning phase:
Jul –Sept 2009
Dec 2009 – Sept 2015 |
Learning phase:
Primary = 72
Secondary = 218
Scale up phase:
Primary = 2,327
Secondary =8,436 |
Number of TOT and rollout trainings, number of providers trained, and number of clients served |
- 2,328 clinicians trained through 98 TTT sessions
- 8,436 health extension workers trained
- 1,382,318 women received contraceptive services, including 1,273,990 contraceptive implants
|
National scale up |
| Williams et al. (2014) Effectiveness of Train-the-Trainer HIV Education: A Model from Vietnam |
HIV |
Vietnam |
Quantitative
Impact & outcome evaluation
Pre-experimental: pre-post single group design |
2006-2012 |
Primary = 87
Secondary =67,338 |
HIV knowledge, self-report of attitudes toward PLWH, self-confidence regarding ability to care for PLWH and self-confidence regarding teaching skills |
- 87 nurses participated in training to become HIV trainers
- HIV knowledge and teaching self- confidence increased significantly
- The 87 nurses reported training over 67,000 health care workers
- Health care workers demonstrated increased HIV knowledge and increased willingness to provide nursing care for HIV-infected patients
|
National |