JEE indicators Ministries and agencies Key gaps and overlaps
PREVENT - National legislation, policy and financing No ministry designated as responsible GAP: Disaster declaration at the local level; emergency or disaster funding
PREVENT- International health regulations coordination, communication and advocacy Ministry of Health, One Health Platform GAP: Coordination between sub-national and national levels and international cooperation
PREVENT - Immunization Ministry of Health, Ministry of Livestock & One Health Platform GAP: Manufacturers liability; technical standards for vaccine storage; zoonotic vaccination; free vaccination; prioritization of access; quality regulation; stockpile management; emergency vaccination; coordination with human prophylaxis in the event of a zoonotic outbreak; lists of compulsory vaccinations in animals
PREVENT - Zoonotic diseases Ministry of Livestock & One Health Platform GAP: Mandatory sharing of information relevant to health security to human and environmental health authorities; licensing, control & regulation of slaughterhouses; transhumance and transfer of animals nationally and internationally; sanitary police and international transhumance (eg, import of international game and compulsory sanitary certificate from country of origin); prevention activities focused on livestock or poultry production systems; lists of compulsory vaccinations in animals
PREVENT - Biosafety and biosecurity Ministry of Health, One Health Platform GAP: Roles and responsibilities of national laboratories network in surveillance and reporting activities; the regulation of biological agents and toxins; transport and handling of biological substances; laboratory (research or clinical) waste management
DETECT - National laboratory system Ministry of Health, One Health Platform GAP: Roles and responsibilities of national laboratories network in surveillance and reporting activities; the regulation of biological agents and toxins; transport and handling of biological substances; laboratory (research or clinical) waste management; mandatory sharing of diagnostic information relevant to health security to animal and environmental health authorities; no provisions to facilitate sharing of samples across sectors; no provision for inclusion of environmental health laboratories
OVERLAP: mandates pertaining to laboratory standards setting; overlapping assignment of responsibilities to specific entities (ie, National Public Health Institute; Laboratory Technical Group of the One Health Platform and the National Directorate of Medical Biology)
DETECT - Surveillance Ministry of Health, Ministry of Livestock, Ministry of Environment, One Health Platform GAP: List of diseases of epidemic potential in the public health code; scope of surveillance; full list of core functions and activities undertaken by the agency; mandatory sharing of information relevant to health security to animal and environmental health authorities; full list of core functions and activities undertaken by the National Health Security agency; full list of core functions and activities undertaken by the ministry to undertake effective surveillance measures
OVERLAP: Overlapping mandates across agencies and ministries; conflicting assignments of responsibilities to specific entities or stakeholders
DETECT - Reporting Ministry of Health, Ministry of Livestock GAP: Mandatory sharing of information with animal and environmental health authorities regarding diseases with potential impact to the livestock/agricultural/wildlife sectors, if first detected in humans; specific inclusion of the private sector for reporting on disease incidence; mandatory information sharing regarding zoonotic infectious diseases cases to human & environmental health authorities where relevant
REPSOND – Emergency response operations Ministry of Health, One Health Platform GAP: Collaboration between all concerned ministries and information sharing between all actors involved in humanitarian crises response; no designated focal point for inter-agency cooperation
OVERLAP: Unclear assignments of responsibilities and oversight between the National Health Security agency’s Emergency Operation Center and the Emergency Operation Centers referred to in the One Health Decree (2017); no clear de-conflicting of roles and responsibilities with the National Committee on the Management of Catastrophes
RESPOND - Linking public health and security authorities National government, Ministry of Defense GAP: Inclusion of law enforcement agencies, particularly for joint investigation; protection of civilian rights during security response; delineation of authorities between health and security officials during public health emergency
RESPOND - Medical countermeasures and personnel deployment No ministry designated as responsible GAP: Visas for international assistance personnel; processes for procuring/receiving medical counter measures during an emergency
RESPOND - risk communication Ministry of Health, One Health Platform GAP: Operational risk communication (or any risk communication outside of immunizations)
RESPOND - Case management, quarantine, and compulsory measures Ministry of Health, Ministry of Livestock, Ministry of Environment GAP: Criteria for quarantine or placing individuals under observation; distinction between isolation and quarantine measures; distinction between animal and human quarantine; criteria for port of entry denials; assigning responsibilities to specific departments; coordination with the Ministry Of Health with respect to restricting the movement of people when they themselves are suspected of being infected
OVERLAP: potential conflict between Public Health Code (Ministry of Health) and Code of Livestock (Ministry of Livestock) related to authority to prescribe quarantine measures for zoonotic diseases. Direct overlap between the National Health Security Agency and the National Directorate for Epidemiology and Disease Prevention (or Direction Nationale de l’Epidémiologie et de la lutte contre la Maladie in French) related to case management
Other international health regulations-related hazards and points of entry Ministry of Environment GAP: no provision on response to chemical events; no mention of radio-nuclear hazards; no criteria for port of entry denials
OVERLAP: potential overlap of authorities between Ministry of Livestock and Ministry of Environment regarding regulation of cross-border movement of animals